Sunday, November 15, 2026

The Process Is Part of the Product: How My Teaching Experience Shaped My AP® Art Curriculum

More than a decade of teaching AP® Art and Design has taught me that the strongest curriculum develops through experience, reflection, and revision.

In a World of AI-Generated Resources, Experience Matters

I've been thinking a lot lately about AI and what it means for teachers who purchase curriculum resources.

Don't get me wrong. I think AI can be a really useful tool, and I can certainly appreciate anything that helps teachers save time. But it's also becoming harder to tell how much thought and experience have gone into the resources we're purchasing.

With AI, it's possible to put together an entire unit, complete with lesson plans, presentations, and rubrics, in a matter of minutes. And some of those materials look pretty impressive.

But I keep coming back to one question: Has anyone actually taught this?

Because there's a big difference between an assignment that looks good on paper and one that works well with a classroom full of students.

Sometimes the instructions that seemed perfectly clear when you wrote them leave half the class confused. Sometimes an activity you planned for 30 minutes takes two class periods. Sometimes students come up with interpretations of an assignment that you never anticipated, and you realize you need to rethink the way you introduced it.

And sometimes an assignment works really well, but after teaching it a few times, you realize there are ways to make it even better.

That's where experience makes a difference.

I've been teaching AP® Art and Design courses since 2014, and I can tell you that my curriculum has changed quite a bit over those years. Some of those changes have been substantial. Others have been small adjustments that came from noticing something in class and thinking, There's probably a better way to do this.

The resources I use today are the result of all those years of teaching, reflecting, and making adjustments.

An early photo from my teaching career in 2011. I've been developing and refining my approach to teaching art for many years, including teaching AP® courses since 2014.

My Curriculum Has Become a Sustained Investigation of Its Own

A while back, I started thinking about how much my curriculum development has in common with the artistic process I ask my students to follow.

In fact, I think my curriculum has become a sustained investigation of its own.

If you're familiar with AP® Art and Design, you know how much emphasis is placed on inquiry, practice, experimentation, and revision. Students are expected to explore ideas, investigate possibilities, and make decisions based on what they discover along the way.

That's pretty much what I've been doing with my curriculum for the past 12 years.

I've tried different ways of organizing the course. I've experimented with the order in which I introduce concepts, the types of assignments students complete, and how frequently I ask them to stop and reflect on their progress.

I've revised the way students develop their inquiries, document their experimentation, and present evidence of their thinking.

And I've asked myself a lot of questions along the way.

How much structure is helpful, and at what point does it start limiting students' creativity? How can I encourage students to experiment when they would rather stick with an idea they already know they can execute successfully? How can I make reflection meaningful instead of just giving students another writing assignment to complete?

I haven't always gotten those things right the first time. Actually, I've probably learned just as much from the things that didn't work as I have from the things that did.

I've also completed my own sustained investigation to better understand the process from a student's perspective. Working through an inquiry myself gave me a different appreciation for the challenges students face, particularly when it comes to developing ideas, experimenting with materials, and figuring out where to go next.

Of course, I've also benefited from professional development, trainings, and conversations with other art educators. I take what I've learned from those experiences and consider how to make it work for my students.

What I have now isn't a curriculum I sat down and wrote all at once. It's something I've been developing, testing, and revising for years.

And I'm still working on it.

Curriculum development doesn't end when the school day does. Reflecting, revising, and preparing are ongoing parts of my teaching practice.

Helping Students See the Value of Experimentation

One thing I've learned from teaching advanced art students is that experimentation doesn't always come naturally, even to students who are really talented.

Sometimes it's actually the students with strong technical skills who resist it the most.

They have an idea. They know how to make it. They're ready to get started.

And then I ask them to experiment with something before they begin their final work.

I understand their frustration. If you've already figured out how you want something to look, it can feel unnecessary to spend time testing other possibilities.

But I've also seen what happens when students take the time to explore. They discover materials or techniques they hadn't considered. They find solutions to problems before those problems become part of a finished piece. Sometimes their original idea changes entirely.

Over the years, I've made quite a few changes to my project development assignments and progress checks to encourage more of this kind of thinking.

I want students to understand that experimentation isn't just something they need to document for their portfolio. It can actually make their artwork better. Here's a good example:



A student's planning and experimentation with color, transparency, texture, and thread. Multiple tests helped the student identify what wasn't working and explore alternatives before completing the artwork.

The student wanted to create a transparent effect over a realistic image of a hand. Looking at the documentation, you can see that several attempts didn't produce the effect the student wanted.

The colors were too dark in one experiment. Another was too saturated. Some of the materials weren't transparent enough, and one attempt created a texture that was competing with the hand underneath.

Eventually, the student began testing thread and embroidery as another possibility.

I love seeing this kind of work because the student isn't just making a bunch of samples to check off a requirement. Each experiment has a purpose. The student is evaluating the results, identifying problems, and using that information to make decisions.

That's what I want students to learn how to do.

And it's why I've spent so much time refining the assignments that guide them through that process.

Structure Without Sacrificing Student Choice

Finding the right balance between structure and student choice has probably been one of the biggest challenges I've worked through with my curriculum.

I know students need guidance. Even my most independent students benefit from having clear expectations, checkpoints, and opportunities for feedback.

But I also don't want every student completing an assignment in exactly the same way.

I want their ideas to determine the direction of their work.

That's why I've developed a series of assignments that help students plan, experiment, reflect, and revise without telling them exactly what they need to create.

I've also become much more flexible about how students document their process.

Some of my students are great at explaining their thinking through writing. Others communicate much more effectively through sketches, photographs, and annotations. And some do a combination of all three.

As long as they're providing meaningful evidence of their thinking and meeting the requirements of the assignment, I'm generally comfortable giving them some freedom in how they organize and present that information.

This doesn't mean there aren't expectations. There absolutely are.

But I'm more interested in what their documentation tells me about their artistic decisions than whether everyone's work looks the same.

In this example, the student explored the issue of overfishing and its relationship to human activity.

The documentation shows how the student planned the arrangement of the fish, worked through the composition, experimented with color, and eventually incorporated actual netting into the finished work.

I think this is a great example of why I've moved toward allowing more flexibility in how students present their process.

The student is communicating a lot of information about the development of the artwork, but doing so primarily through visual evidence and annotations.

That makes sense for an art class.

And for me, it's much more useful than asking every student to fill out identical boxes on a worksheet, regardless of how they work best.

Created for Real Students in a Real Classroom

Here's something else that has influenced my curriculum quite a bit: My students are all different.

That probably sounds obvious, but it's easy to forget when we're planning lessons.

Some students enter my advanced classes with exceptional technical skills but have a hard time coming up with ideas that go beyond what they already know how to do.

Others have fascinating ideas but need a lot of help figuring out how to communicate them visually.

Some students can take a fairly open-ended assignment and run with it. Others need more direction, examples, or opportunities to talk through their thinking.

And because I teach multiple levels of art within the same class period, I've had to think carefully about how to provide those different levels of support.

I've learned that the resources I create need to be structured enough to help students who struggle with the process, but flexible enough that students who are ready to work more independently don't feel restricted.

That hasn't always been easy to accomplish.

Sometimes I revise an assignment because I realize students need more guidance at the beginning. Other times, I remove requirements because they're getting in the way of the creative process.

And sometimes I discover that the most useful part of an assignment isn't something I originally planned at all.

Conversations about artwork are an important part of the creative process. My students regularly discuss their ideas, receive feedback, and consider their next steps.

My resources provide a framework, but the most meaningful teaching often happens in the conversations that develop around the artwork.

Sometimes a student needs help solving a technical problem. Sometimes they need someone to ask a question that encourages them to push their idea further. And sometimes they just need reassurance that an experiment that didn't turn out as planned can still lead somewhere interesting.

These experiences continue to shape the way I design assignments, assessments, and opportunities for reflection.

Revision Isn't a Sign That Something Failed

I think one of the hardest things for students to accept is that changing their minds can be a good thing.

They've already invested time in an idea. They've made sketches, gathered materials, and maybe even started their final artwork.

Then they realize something isn't working.

Some students are willing to make changes right away. Others need a little convincing.

I try to help them understand that revision doesn't necessarily mean starting over or abandoning everything they've done. Sometimes it means recognizing that there's a better way to communicate what they're trying to say.

In this example, the student was exploring how pigeons have gone from being valued for their usefulness to being viewed by many people as pests.

The student experimented with different media and approaches to the background before developing the final digital composition.

One of the changes I find especially interesting is the decision to distinguish between the historical and contemporary environments through the background imagery.

You can follow that thinking through the student's planning and revisions.

I like using examples like this because students can see that decisions aren't necessarily final just because they've already started making something.

And I've realized that the same thing applies to my teaching.

There are assignments I've used for years that I still change when I discover something that works better.

I don't think there's anything wrong with revising a curriculum that's already successful. Why wouldn't I want to keep improving it?

Always Revising, Always Learning

Of course, some revisions happen because the course itself changes.

With the release of the updated AP® Art and Design Course and Exam Description for Fall 2026, I went back through my curriculum to review what needed updating.

I revised student resources, assignments, scoring tools, and other course materials to reflect the updated guidance, including changes related to the use of artificial intelligence.

It was a significant amount of work, especially because I also needed to update the Canvas course that accompanies my curriculum.

But that's part of maintaining a resource that I continue to use in my own classroom.

And the official updates are only one reason I make changes.

Just this year, I've revised assignments because students needed clearer examples. I've adjusted rubrics when I realized the criteria weren't communicating exactly what I wanted students to demonstrate. I've changed how students submit reflection evidence because I found a format that works better for my classes.

Some of those changes are fairly small, but they add up.

I've also learned that what works for one group of students doesn't necessarily work as well for the next. As a result, I try not to become so attached to a particular assignment or routine that I'm unwilling to reconsider it.

After all, if I'm asking my students to reflect on their choices and revise their work, I should be doing the same.

Sharing What I've Learned

When I started sharing my curriculum on Teachers Pay Teachers, I wasn't starting from scratch to create something to sell.

I was organizing and sharing the resources I'd already developed and used with my students.

And those resources represent a lot of years of work.

My Complete Course Guide for Teaching AP® Drawing and 2-D Art and Design includes an 18-week course structure, daily agendas, project assignments, development and progress checks, reflection activities, critiques, and other resources I use to help students develop their portfolios.

I also offer a version that includes my Canvas course, with the materials organized for teachers who want to use them through their learning management system.

I know that no two art classrooms operate exactly the same way. What works for my students might need to be adjusted for yours.

That's why I've tried to make the materials flexible enough that teachers can adapt them to their own teaching styles, schedules, and students.

I'm not suggesting that purchasing my curriculum means you'll never need to create another assignment or make another instructional decision. I wouldn't want that kind of curriculum for myself, either.

What I hope it provides is a strong starting point, with thoughtfully developed resources that teachers can use, adjust, and build upon.

And there's something else I want teachers to know.

When you purchase my curriculum, you're not limited to the version that exists on the day you buy it.

As I continue to revise my materials, I share updates with previous purchasers. When I made the recent changes to align with the updated course guidance, for example, I wanted the teachers who had already purchased my curriculum to benefit from those revisions, too.

My plan is to continue sharing updates for as long as I'm teaching and maintaining these resources.

And since I have about 13 years before I can even consider retirement, I don't think I'll be finished revising anytime soon!

The Process Really Is Part of the Product

I know there are a lot of curriculum resources available to teachers, and with AI becoming more common, I imagine that number will only continue to grow.

I'm not opposed to AI. I think it has its place, and I use technology to make my own work more efficient.

But I also think there's something important about knowing where a resource came from and how it was developed.

When I look through my curriculum, I can remember why certain assignments are structured the way they are. I can think of students who struggled with something and prompted me to revise it. I can remember ideas that didn't work quite the way I expected, along with the changes I made afterward.

Those experiences have shaped what I teach and how I teach it.

And they're not things that can be replicated simply by generating a polished set of materials.

The value of my curriculum isn't just the collection of assignments, presentations, and rubrics. It's the experience that went into developing them, and the fact that I continue to teach, reflect, and revise.

I expect my curriculum will look a little different next year. And probably the year after that, too.

I actually hope it does.


Explore My Curriculum Resources

If you're teaching AP® Drawing or 2-D Art and Design and looking for resources that provide structure while still allowing students plenty of room to develop their own ideas, you're welcome to take a look at the curriculum I've developed.

These are the materials I use in my own classroom, and I'll continue updating them as I learn and refine my teaching.

Complete Course Guide for Teaching AP® Drawing and 2-D Art and Design

Complete Course Guide + Canvas Course

AP® is a trademark registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse, this website or its products.

No comments: